An Investigation of the Relationship between Personality Traits and Performance for Engineering and Architectural Professionals Providing Design Services to the Building Sector of the Construction Industry

Author: Carr, Paul Gerard

Advisor: Professor Jesus M. de la Garza

Educational level: PhD

Discipline: Civil Engineering

University: Virginia Tech

Abstract: An Investigation of the Relationship between Personality Traits and Performance for Engineering and Architectural Professionals Providing Design Services to the Building Sector of the Construction IndustrybyPaul Gerard Carr, P.E.Professor Jesus M. de la Garza, Ph.D., Co-ChairProfessor Michael C. Vorster, Ph.D. Co-ChairCivil Engineering(ABSTRACT) One of the prominent trends in business organizations today is the attention placed on individual Personality traits to predict job performance. Distinct Personality characteristics of members of various work groups must be carefully considered so that the assignment of individuals to work teams results in Successful Behaviors and performance improvements. The particular task assignment to various work groups, and thus assignments to individuals, will affect performance. It is critical that these individuals possess both the abilities and Behavioral preferences to create conditions that promote the highest probability for Success. Contingent variables will always be present in any decision-based action, particularly in complex situations, however, when an individual holds a native preference for a Successful pattern of Behaviors in a certain task’s realm, higher overall organizational performance may be expected. As such, the current study investigates the impact of various Personality traits and patterns on critical Success Behaviors in the Engineering and Architectural profession’s project design services. The four project service categories measured in the Critical Success Factors Questionnaire are: Planning (Conceptual Design), Design (Contract Documents), Construction (Administration) and Firm Management duties. The measurement of the individual personalities is accomplished in this investigation through the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator ® (MBTI). This psychometric instrument measures one’s attitudes in dealing with the outside world, as well as one’s preferences for data collection and decision making.On an individual basis, it was predicted that persons with personalities whose preferences were towards openness to new ideas, and resistant to closure of the discovery process, would perform well on planning or conceptual design tasks. It was predicted that those with a preference towards compliance with rules, regulations and thorough adherence to established standards, would outperform on tasks of detailed design. The research work also offered a prediction of high performance from persons with a preference for innovative ideas and openness to alternatives in the administration of construction, and predicted a contrast with personalities that vary from this pattern.Of the 85-person sample, it was found that those possessing a preference for Intuitive data collection (MBTI Dichotomy, N) and Perceiving structure, (MBTI Dichotomy, P), outperformed individuals with preferences for Sensing and Judging, (MBTI Dichotomies S and J), in both Planning and Construction Administration. However, professionals with a Personality favoring Judging, outperformed in the duties associated with the Design Phase. Contrary to predictions, the decision processes captured in the Thinking/Feeling MBTI® dichotomy (MBTI, T/F) did not meditate the performance in any of the four service categories.The results of the Research indicate a greater utility for Personality measures as a diagnostic tool for team and individual performance interventions, rather than a tool for team selection or team-building. The implications of the results of this research, and recommendations for future investigations are discussed.

Visit Source URL

Download full report

Keywords: Critical Incidents, Behavior, Success, Personality


More from Virginia Tech

(view more...) Add to list

Abstract: A 5' AMP-degrading activity appears during the course of development in Dictyostelium discoideum between the prestalk and prespore zones. This enzyme is referred as 5'-Nucleotidase (5NT). Given the critical role of cyclic AMP in cell differentiation in this organism, 5NT is thought to be involved in cell positioning...

'A new tempered spirit to comfort the twenty-first century': individual choices, public policies, and the philanthropic experience in Western Europe (view more...) Add to list

Abstract: This essay examines the persistent and penetrating role of philanthropy in the institutional life of Western Europe. Whatever knowledge has been gained in the collective survival of Homo sapiens, our species derives its authority over history from a purpose more significant than simply the survival of the fittest or the...

'SUSTAINABILITY AS A DESIGN TOOL'a sustainable biology and chemistry teaching laboratory for Georgetown University in Washington D.C."inform[ation]al backbone" (view more...) Add to list

Abstract: Like much of the world, the United States is currently experiencing intense growth, especially in and around its cities. Unfortunately, this growth is often at odds with the natural environment. In order to reduce the demand of foreign energy resources designing with "green" or ecologically responsive design objectives in mind...

More related to Civil Engineering

“Smart” Sensors for Civil Infrastructure Systems (view more...) Add to list

Abstract: "Smart" sensors with embedded microprocessors and wireless communication linkshave the potential to change fundamentally the way civil infrastructure systems are monitored,controlled, and maintained. A 2002 National Research Council report noted that theuse of networked systems of embedded computers and sensors throughout society couldwell dwarf all previous milestones in the information...

 Certain modified approaches for digital analysis of multispectral data. (view more...) Add to list

Abstract: Classification is the most important amongst digital analysis of Remotely Sensed (RS) Multispectral (MS) data and the process of discrimination, identification and grouping of data into meaningful landcover types based on their spectral responses. Accuracy and applicability of the results of classification are greatly influenced not only by the spectral...

 Finite element analysis of layered composite and stiffened shells based onrefined theories. (view more...) Add to list

Abstract: In recent years, there has been wide ranging applications of shell structures made of composite materials. The use of classical laminated and the first order shear deformation shell theories have been found to be inadequate for the reliable analysis of such shear deformable structures. In this work, the development of...